Tony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Slice House

Div a month ago

Tony’s pizza was far from good. In fact far from decent. Starting off with the atmosphere, it was a to go spot so nothing really to say there. Grab and go. Takes a while for your premade pizza slice to be “heated up”. The service was also quick and snappy. NOW THE FOOD!! I had the classic cheese pizza and a vegetarian. The cheese pizza tasted like cardboard. I am not sure if this was given to me room temperature or if it was heated at all. It tasted like it was made yesterday. The cheese was very leathery and the crust was very hard. Barely any sauce. Overall very hard to bite into. The veg pizza was a little better. Had more flavor and sauce as well. The feta was a nice touch. But even then, it would have been a decent pizza slice if it was heated properly. Overall 2/10.

Janeandmel 2 months ago

Stopped in to grab some slices to take to our hotel room. For take home slice pizza it was pretty good. Would loved to have sat down and tried their specialty there. Kind of a pizza geek after spending lots of time in NYC touring pizza and taking classes to learn the art of pizza making at home. Hope that their restaurant version is better than the slice take out. Saw a lot of Tony's boxes around town so clearly it's a popular spot.

Fernán Oviedo 3 months ago

Spectacular pizza. Delicious taste with nice crispy bottom. Despite their generous size and thinness, they're quite easy to pick up and eat without making a mess. Would highly recommend getting a slice and having it at Washington Square Park right across.

Fofirl 5 months ago

Ordered Sicilian Combo. For my first experience I ordered just a slice. It looks great in the display case. I received bread with a super spicy sauce as if tomatoes and oregano didn’t exist. You would think there would be cheese and all the toppings listed even if it was just a little bit. It had nothing.

Josh Zignego 6 months ago

We just got slices because the wait time was 2 hours for the main restaurant. The margarita was phenomenal, the sauce was great, and the crust was crunchy. Definitely lived up to the hype.